Skip to main content

Redesigning the Speculum: How Designers Are Tackling a 170-Year-Old Medical Tool

It was a quiet afternoon in the San Francisco headquarters of Frog, the renowned global design firm best known for helping shape the iconic aesthetic of products like Apple’s original Macintosh computers. Hailey Stewart, one of Frog’s dedicated industrial designers, had arranged an eclectic array of prototypes across a large table. At one end sat cylinders of foam resembling sleek, contemporary wellness devices, accompanied by varied handles extending at different angles alongside rough sketches of levers and screw mechanisms. At the opposite end lay the conventional speculum—the cold, clinical medical device that has been utilized for generations during routine gynecological examinations to inspect the cervix.

Stewart picked up a standard speculum and cranked it open. The device emitted a loud, jarring, and painful-sounding mechanical click. "You’re literally in the stirrups with that sound," Stewart noted, expressing the visceral dread many patients feel, "and it’s like, excuse my language, but what the fuck?"

Most of the designers gathered in the room had never actually laid eyes on a speculum before that day. Several of the male designers admitted they had never truly considered the complex and vulnerable realities of a pelvic examination—the process of stripping off one’s clothes, lying flat on an examination table, and strapping feet into cold metal stirrups while a practitioner pries open the body using a rigid metal gadget. But Stewart had not convened her colleagues merely to recount the standard routine of an annual women’s health exam. She had brought them together to pursue a much larger and more ambitious goal.

For the preceding several months, primarily working during their off-hours and weekends, Stewart and interaction designer Sahana Kumar had immersed themselves in studying the century-old medical tool. They had wrenched it open and closed repeatedly, analyzed the exact curvature of the bills, and read extensively about its complicated history. Now, standing before the rest of the design team at Frog, they announced that they were officially taking on a particularly challenging project: completely redesigning the speculum for the 21st century.

The current underlying architecture of the speculum dates back to the 1840s, famously fashioned by American physician James Marion Sims. The original instrument featured two pewter bills designed to separate the vaginal walls, hinged together with a screw mechanism that allowed it to open and close. Sims, frequently referred to in medical histories as the "father of modern gynecology," utilized the speculum to pioneer crucial early treatments for vesicovaginal fistula and other severe complications stemming from childbirth. However, his pioneering medical experiments were infamously conducted on enslaved women without the administration of anesthesia. To state that the speculum was originally created without patient comfort as a primary design consideration would be an egregious understatement.

Despite the profound advancements in medical science and technology over the past century and a half, the speculum used in clinical offices today looks remarkably identical to the one Sims employed more than 150 years ago. The most noticeable evolutionary difference between the original Sims apparatus and contemporary versions found in modern gynecological clinics is the material: rather than heavy pewter, today’s specula are typically manufactured from stainless steel or medical-grade plastic.

The mere fact that the speculum is an old invention is not, on its face, an inherent problem. Rather, the fundamental issue is that the traditional design is poorly optimized for both patients and physicians. Healthcare providers are frequently forced to stretch the instrument’s bills wide open in order to gain a clear line of sight to the cervix located deep within the vaginal canal. Even when forced to maximum expansion, achieving a clear view is not always guaranteed. While some specula are manufactured with built-in light sources, the clinical challenge frequently stems from surrounding tissue collapsing inward rather than a lack of illumination in the canal. All of that mechanical pressure causes significant physical discomfort. In fact, a comprehensive review of existing medical literature highlighted that a notable portion of female patients actively delay or entirely avoid scheduling routine gynecological visits due to their dread of the examination and the instrument itself.

The psychological and physical tolls have drawn institutional scrutiny as well. In 2014, the American College of Physicians took the extraordinary step of officially recommending against routine screening pelvic examinations for average-risk adult women, explicitly citing the harms, fear, anxiety, embarrassment, pain, and discomfort associated with speculum-based examinations. These negative side effects directly impact gynecologists and healthcare providers as well. As Stewart points out, patient efficiency is directly tied to comfort. The more comfortable and relaxed a patient is during an examination, the faster and more smoothly a clinician can perform their duties, allowing them to care for a greater number of patients overall. Consequently, there is an actual, measurable monetary value attached to patient comfort.

The Speculum Finally Gets a Modern Redesign

It is not as though innovators have completely ignored the problem over the years. In 2005, a San Francisco-based startup patented the design for an inflatable speculum known as FemSpec. Constructed out of polyurethane—the exact same material utilized in the manufacturing of condoms—the device was intended to be inserted by a physician much like a tampon and then inflated gently like a tiny medical balloon. It initially debuted to a moderate amount of industry fanfare, but ultimately commercialized poorly and faded from widespread use. As a feature article in The Chicago Times observed at the time, the vast majority of women never even had the opportunity to experience the innovative new speculum simply because it was so novel on the market that most traditional doctors never adopted it into their daily practice.

Other design iterations have focused on more modest, incremental improvements. A notable student prototype called the Lotus, designed by a creative student at the Pratt Institute, preserved the traditional bill shape of the standard speculum but curved the edges slightly to facilitate a more ergonomic insertion process. That particular design also incorporated a rotating handle intended to open the bills vertically, alongside a hidden lever mechanism designed to prevent accidental pinching of sensitive tissue. While the concept generated significant industry buzz after appearing in a student design showcase, it never transitioned into a commercially viable manufactured product.

Meanwhile, in Oregon, a dedicated medical device startup named Ceek Women’s Health has undertaken clinical trials for an entirely new suite of gynecological tools. Their product lineup includes a protective sleeve, a speculum engineered with narrower bills, and an alternative speculum designed specifically for patient self-insertion. The overarching philosophy of the company is to manufacture a diverse toolkit of specula tailored to serve a wide variety of patient body types and medical histories, rather than continuing to rely on a monolithic, one-size-fits-all instrument. Fahti Khosrow, the co-founder and CEO of Ceek, emphasizes that traditional products fail to address the needs of women with varying anatomical structures, high body mass indexes, histories of trauma or sexual assault, or post-menopausal vaginal atrophy. Providing physicians with a modernized, multifaceted toolkit allows them to better serve their diverse patient populations.

Perhaps the most radical departure from traditional hardware comes out of Duke University, where academic researchers are actively testing a revolutionary device designed to bypass the speculum entirely. Mercy Asiedu, a biomedical engineering doctoral candidate at Duke, spearheaded the creation of a tampon-sized optical device equipped with a high-resolution two-megapixel camera mounted directly at the tip. Explaining the rationale behind the alternative approach, Asiedu noted that while the traditional speculum was originally invented to allow a physician to view the cervix from completely outside the body, modern micro-technology makes it entirely feasible to safely view the cervix from inside the body.

Asiedu evaluated her prototype during a pilot clinical study involving 15 volunteer participants, with the encouraging results published in the peer-reviewed journal PLOS One. Every single participating patient reported that the significantly smaller, camera-equipped device provided a vastly superior and more comfortable experience than the traditional metal or plastic speculum.

While the Duke study highlighted high levels of patient satisfaction, Asiedu openly acknowledges that practicing physicians may offer more operational criticism of the device. The academic design prioritized patient comfort, personal modesty, and bodily empowerment over absolute ease of use for the clinician. With a standard speculum, a provider can simply insert the tool and expand it as wide as necessary to achieve immediate visualization. By contrast, the miniature camera device requires the clinician to insert it and gently maneuver it around the canal in a manner reminiscent of a joystick.

When Stewart and her multidisciplinary team at Frog initially set out to tackle the speculum redesign, they were fully aware of the steep historical and clinical hurdles standing in their way. Compounding the challenge, Stewart candidly admitted that prior to launching the initiative, she had never even personally laid eyes on a speculum.

Before conducting formal technical research or putting pen to paper for preliminary sketches, Stewart and Kumar compiled a comprehensive list of every element that consistently frustrated them during personal gynecological examinations. The complaints spanned multiple sensory categories: the abrasive and anxiety-inducing noise reminiscent of a mechanical kitchen can opener, the freezing cold temperature of the metal, and the uncomfortable internal sensation of tissue being forcibly stretched like a heavy rubber band. Once they acquired an assortment of physical specula—one plastic and one metal—they quickly realized that the visual aesthetics required a complete overhaul. To modern eyes, the instruments closely resembled medieval torture devices rather than compassionate healthcare tools.

Stewart’s first technical objective was addressing the harsh ratcheting sound produced by the opening mechanism. Working closely with Fran Wang, a mechanical engineer at Frog, the pair investigated entirely novel methods for opening and expanding the device. No conceptual idea was deemed too unorthodox. They pondered whether they could use saline solution to inflate the device from the inside much like a pufferfish, or utilize compressed air to expand it gently akin to an air mattress. They sought creative inspiration from the natural world, studying the intimidating hood of a cobra, alongside industrial machining concepts like milling chucks and everyday items including bicycle pumps. They closely examined the clamping mechanics of camera tripods and the precise clip-in mechanisms of ski bindings, relentlessly searching for mechanical concepts that could successfully replace the antiquated screw mechanism.

The Speculum Finally Gets a Modern Redesign

Next, the design team re-evaluated the materials used in manufacturing. Moving away from rigid plastics and cold metals, they decided to encase the entire structural apparatus in medical-grade autoclavable silicone—a resilient material that retains ambient room temperature, undergoes straightforward sterilization procedures, and dramatically softens the physical sensation of insertion. Wang emphasized the practical benefits of the material choice, noting that traditional metal specula feature sharp, exposed edges that should never come into close contact with delicate human tissue. Covering the framework in smooth silicone prevents accidental tissue trauma while simultaneously presenting a much softer, more approachable visual appearance.

Experimentation continued through various structural configurations. The team tested a three-pronged architecture that expanded outward into a clean triangle shape, contrasted with ideas to shrink the overall footprint to the size of a tampon or borrow sleek design languages from the modern consumer vibrator industry. They tested handle angles ranging from 90 degrees to 120 degrees to determine the most physically ergonomic posture for physicians performing the exam. Following these iterations, they utilized 3D-printing technology to rapidly fabricate physical prototypes, placing them directly into the hands of practicing OB/GYNs and clinical medical providers for real-world feedback.

The clinical response was overwhelmingly positive regarding specific features. Obstetricians and gynecologists were particularly enthusiastic about the prototype that opened using three distinct bills rather than the traditional two. The resulting triangular opening successfully provided clinicians with an equivalent visual field of the cervix without requiring the bills to be expanded as widely, thereby reducing the painful stretching sensation for patients. Practitioners also praised the revised handle positioned at a 110-degree angle, which successfully created sufficient physical clearance between the provider’s hand and the patient’s body, eliminating the awkward final adjustments traditionally required on the examination table. The silicone exterior coating was hailed as a major functional victory, and a simple push-button locking mechanism allowed providers to operate the device securely with a single hand while leaving the other free. Furthermore, the newly engineered opening mechanism was completely silent.

However, consultations with medical professionals made one critical reality starkly apparent: redesigning the hardware alone would not be enough to fundamentally fix the patient experience. Stewart reflected on why she personally felt significantly more comfortable undergoing a routine bikini wax than attending an annual gynecological checkup, concluding that the disparity largely stemmed from the surrounding environment. The clinical exam room felt cold, sterile, and intimidating, whereas personal care appointments felt relaxing and personalized, despite involving substantial physical pain. If the team truly wanted to revolutionize the speculum, they realized they had to redesign the entire clinical ecosystem surrounding the exam.

Within half a year, the initiative evolved into a comprehensive conceptual overhaul of the modern pelvic examination. The package now encompasses the newly engineered speculum, refined continually through ongoing consultations with a collaborative board of OB/GYNs. It also includes an established set of clinical guidelines for healthcare providers, featuring simple yet profoundly meaningful recommendations such as providing patients with a designated place to hang their garments and thoroughly explaining each step of the examination before it begins. Kumar emphasized that while the clinical encounter will never be entirely effortless, the primary goal is to emotionally prepare individuals for the experience and ensure they walk away feeling respected and valued.

The comprehensive ecosystem also features a detailed mockup for a companion mobile application, designed to allow patients to seamlessly complete administrative paperwork, submit confidential inquiries, or follow a guided meditation exercise in the waiting room prior to their examination. To complement the physical hardware, Kumar invented a dedicated patient comfort kit containing items such as a stress ball and soft socks to cover bare feet in the stirrups. Joined by Rachel Hobart, a visual designer at Frog who assisted in branding the initiative, the team unified the concept under a distinct identity named Yona.

At present, the Yona project remains an early-stage design concept. Stewart and Wang continue refining the mechanical iterations of the speculum prototypes, while Kumar and Hobart polish the digital application and patient experience touchpoints. They maintain an active dialogue with their advisory board of physicians to fine-tune the concept, carefully balancing clinical feasibility with patient-centered design. Concurrently, the team is actively seeking forward-thinking healthcare partners—such as tech-enabled medical providers like One Medical—who share a common vision and possess the capability to help transition Yona from a design concept into a commercial reality.

The most formidable obstacle facing the team remains the challenge of widespread clinical adoption. The designers at Frog are acutely aware that numerous previous medical prototypes have faltered because practicing physicians pushed back against investing in novel equipment, either due to the financial cost of purchasing new instrumentation or the mental investment of learning an unfamiliar workflow. Gynecologists have relied on the traditional speculum design for over a century, and the legacy tool technically fulfills its basic function. Why disrupt a system that appears to work? As Stewart noted, an innovator can design the most beautiful, unique, and user-friendly medical device in the world, but if a doctor refuses to learn how to operate it, the patient will never benefit from it.

Nevertheless, Wang remains optimistic, noting that widespread adoption is largely a matter of introducing the product to the market and demonstrating its tangible benefits to both clinicians and patients. She acknowledges that the traditional speculum functions well enough for most practitioners to get the job done. However, she argues that "it passes, but it’s not great." By offering clinicians a clear choice between a familiar legacy tool and a demonstrably superior alternative, providers will naturally gravitate toward the better option once they are given the opportunity to experience it firsthand.

Asro

Author at DesignEnt.

Flash News